In April 2023, it was announced that men's and women's bowling would become the 15th and 16th teams at Goshen College and that Scott Curtis would serve as the first head coach in the program's history. Curtis recruited heavily before the team began competition in September of this year, bringing on 24 bowlers - 13 men and 11 women. In the program's first tournament at the Dirty Bird Classic, Rebekah Muzyk was the top female bowler with 599 pins. She guided the women to a fourth place finish out of 14 teams.
Since then, Brendan Riley has twice been named the Crossroads League Men's Bowler of the Week and Samantha Bean has claimed the award once on the women's side. Goshen competed in their first two Crossroads League tournaments earlier this month and will be hosting one on February 1st in Elkhart.
The city of Goshen has a storied bowling history, and Everingham's honorary membership as a part of the inaugural Goshen College bowling team is connecting the past with the present.