1997 -
Mark Schloneger (Baseball)
2011 - Jan Dohnal (Men's Soccer)
2011 - Greg Thiessen (Men's Soccer)
2011 - Ryan Troyer (Men's Soccer)
2012 - Jacob GunderKline (Men's Track/Cross Country)
2012 -
Samuel Jones (Men's Track/Cross Country)
2012 - Jana Beitler (Softball)
2012 - Erin Helmuth (Women's Track/Cross Country)
2013 - Mitchell Brickson (Men's Track/Cross Country)
2013 - Erin Helmuth (Women's Track/Cross Country)
2017 - Spencer Aeschliman (Men's Soccer)
2018 - Spencer Aeschliman (Men's Soccer)
2023 - Annika Alderfer Fisher (Women's Track/Cross Country)
2024 - Annika Alderfer Fisher (Women's Track/Cross Country)
2024 - Naomi Ross Richer (Women's Track/Cross Country)
2025 - Mercy Chebet (Women's Track/Cross Country)
